Let Agents (REALLY) Work While You Sleep : Why Roo Cloud Needs Tasks Queue 🚀 #9271
cmpdev23
started this conversation in
Feature Requests
Replies: 0 comments
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
-
Summary
Roo Code Cloud is presented as “specialized agents running in the cloud to get stuff done while you sleep.”
In practice, because of context-window constraints and context poisoning, current agents cannot reliably run large tasks autonomously.
Agents are only effective when they process small, highly scoped tasks that complete in 30 seconds to 2 minutes, before context degradation impacts quality. This is true even according to Roo’s own documentation.
For this reason, a cloud agent cannot perform long sequences of high-quality work unless the user manually feeds dozens of small tasks one by one — which eliminates the “run while you sleep” benefit.
A Task Queue system would solve this problem, make Roo Cloud meaningfully superior to on-device agents (Claude Code, Codex in ChatGPT), and give Roo a distinct competitive positioning.
The Problem: Context Poisoning Makes Long Tasks Impossible
Roo’s docs already warn:
“Context poisoning is a persistent issue within a given session. Once a chat session's context is compromised, treat that session as disposable. Starting fresh with a clean context is crucial.”This is the core issue:
1. Large tasks require large context → quality collapses.
No agent today can run a 2-hour task without losing context fidelity.
2. Effective work requires micro-tasks.
Small, sharp tasks with micro-context = high quality.
Large tasks = degraded output and escalating hallucinations.
3. Cloud agents do not solve this.
If a user must constantly check progress, submit new micro-tasks, and wait for completion, we’re not “working while we sleep”. We’re just coding from our phone with worse UX and no IDE.
4. Other agents already exist inside ChatGPT and Claude apps.
So Roo cannot win on convenience.
You must win on workflow architecture, not on form factor.
Why Roo Code Cloud (as currently designed) has limited value
People already pay for ChatGPT and Claude. Roo Cloud must justify why someone should use it instead of the native mobile apps of these larger models.
Today:
Result:
Cloud agents are not eliminating effort; they are just relocating it.
The Missing Piece: A Task Queue
A Task Queue transforms Roo Cloud from a “remote CLI with worse ergonomics” into a true automation engine.
Core Idea
Users should be able to schedule a sequence of micro-tasks, each extremely well-scoped, each designed to run in isolation with a fresh session or clean context.
The agent never handles large tasks, it handles many small ones automatically.
Concrete Example: Updating a 62-File Documentation System
Consider a very common real-world scenario:
you want to update your project’s documentation to ensure it matches the current codebase.
You have 62 Markdown files spread across the documentation folder.
How this works today (with Roo Code or any agent):
You cannot simply ask the agent: “Update my documentation to match the latest code.”
This kind of broad instruction is guaranteed to fail because:
Even Roo Code’s own docs warn that you must avoid long-running tasks and broad context.
Today the workflow looks like this:
You lose your day watching an agent with no autonomy.
With a Task Queue
Total human time: ~7 minutes.
Total agent time: irrelevant — it runs autonomously.
This is the real “work while you sleep” experience.
Why This Beats Orchestrator
Orchestrators decide the subtasks themselves.
That’s the problem.
A human with domain knowledge should define the micro-tasks. Otherwise Output becomes unpredictable.
A Task Queue gives users full control and keeps each step atomic.
Proposed Implementation (Simple Version)
Create Task
Define the prompt and the agent to use.
Schedule
Options:
Each task runs in a fresh session to avoid context poisoning.
Advanced users could script task creation (e.g., generate 62 tasks programmatically).
Why This Is the Best Strategic Positioning for Roo Code
If Roo adds a Task Queue, it becomes:
It positions Roo not as “another coding agent” but as a developer automation pipeline.
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
All reactions