You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Where are you starting? What can you see?
From any room / DM, start typing out a long message in Element X. The composer box will grow as the message gets longer, eventually covering the entire message / room window behind it. This prevents you from being able to read back a longer message line by line and reply to it.
Outcome
What did you expect?
Expected behaviour would be for the composer to grow until a certain point when typing a longer message, but stopping to allow some of the room behind to remain visible to allow you to read back parts of longer messages while forming your reply.
What happened instead?
Composer consumes the entire window, meaning you would have to either try and memorise a very long message while relpying, or close your keyboard frequently to try and read content in the background. This behaviour does not occur on the older Element Android, and every other messaging app (Signal, Whatsapp, SMS etc) also allows you to see some of message behind the composer. We frequently send and receive long messages, so this behaviour makes Element X difficult to use.
In the first example image, most of the room behind has been obscured.
Continuing to type eventually obscures the entire room history
The same message in Element Android (legacy) looks like this. Note that I'm using the rich text composer in the screenshot, but the behaviour is the same for the plain tect composer.
Your phone model
Samsung Note20 Ultra 5G
Operating system version
Android 13
Application version and app store
Element X 0.7.2
Homeserver
Self hosted, Synapse 118.0
Will you send logs?
No
Are you willing to provide a PR?
No
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
90vgt
added
the
T-Defect
Something isn't working: bugs, crashes, hangs and other reported problems
label
Nov 10, 2024
90vgt
changed the title
Message composer consumes entire window and covers messages bahind when crafting long reply
Message composer consumes entire window and covers messages behind when crafting long reply
Nov 10, 2024
Steps to reproduce
From any room / DM, start typing out a long message in Element X. The composer box will grow as the message gets longer, eventually covering the entire message / room window behind it. This prevents you from being able to read back a longer message line by line and reply to it.
Outcome
What did you expect?
Expected behaviour would be for the composer to grow until a certain point when typing a longer message, but stopping to allow some of the room behind to remain visible to allow you to read back parts of longer messages while forming your reply.
What happened instead?
Composer consumes the entire window, meaning you would have to either try and memorise a very long message while relpying, or close your keyboard frequently to try and read content in the background. This behaviour does not occur on the older Element Android, and every other messaging app (Signal, Whatsapp, SMS etc) also allows you to see some of message behind the composer. We frequently send and receive long messages, so this behaviour makes Element X difficult to use.
In the first example image, most of the room behind has been obscured.
Continuing to type eventually obscures the entire room history
The same message in Element Android (legacy) looks like this. Note that I'm using the rich text composer in the screenshot, but the behaviour is the same for the plain tect composer.
Your phone model
Samsung Note20 Ultra 5G
Operating system version
Android 13
Application version and app store
Element X 0.7.2
Homeserver
Self hosted, Synapse 118.0
Will you send logs?
No
Are you willing to provide a PR?
No
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: