Merge pull request #3531 from valentinewallace/2025-01-fix-buggy-route-err

Author: tnull

lightning/src/ln/channelmanager.rs

@@ -14863,6 +14863,7 @@ mod tests {
 			},
 			_ => panic!("unexpected error")
 		}
+		assert!(nodes[0].node.list_recent_payments().is_empty());
 	}
 
 	#[test]

lightning/src/ln/functional_tests.rs

@@ -6483,6 +6483,7 @@ fn test_payment_route_reaching_same_channel_twice() {
 		RecipientOnionFields::secret_only(our_payment_secret), PaymentId(our_payment_hash.0)
 	), false, APIError::InvalidRoute { ref err },
 	assert_eq!(err, &"Path went through the same channel twice"));
+	assert!(nodes[0].node.list_recent_payments().is_empty());
 }
 
 // BOLT 2 Requirements for the Sender when constructing and sending an update_add_htlc message.

lightning/src/ln/outbound_payment.rs

@@ -811,7 +811,7 @@ impl OutboundPayments {
 	{
 		let onion_session_privs = self.add_new_pending_payment(payment_hash, recipient_onion.clone(), payment_id, None, route, None, None, entropy_source, best_block_height)?;
 		self.pay_route_internal(route, payment_hash, &recipient_onion, None, None, payment_id, None,
-			onion_session_privs, node_signer, best_block_height, &send_payment_along_path)
+			&onion_session_privs, node_signer, best_block_height, &send_payment_along_path)
 			.map_err(|e| { self.remove_outbound_if_all_failed(payment_id, &e); e })
 	}
 
@@ -991,7 +991,7 @@ impl OutboundPayments {
 
 		let result = self.pay_route_internal(
 			&route, payment_hash, &recipient_onion, keysend_preimage, invoice_request, payment_id,
-			Some(route_params.final_value_msat), onion_session_privs, node_signer, best_block_height,
+			Some(route_params.final_value_msat), &onion_session_privs, node_signer, best_block_height,
 			&send_payment_along_path
 		);
 		log_info!(
@@ -1000,9 +1000,9 @@ impl OutboundPayments {
 		);
 		if let Err(e) = result {
 			self.handle_pay_route_err(
-				e, payment_id, payment_hash, route, route_params, router, first_hops,
-				&inflight_htlcs, entropy_source, node_signer, best_block_height, logger,
-				pending_events, &send_payment_along_path
+				e, payment_id, payment_hash, route, route_params, onion_session_privs, router, first_hops,
+				&inflight_htlcs, entropy_source, node_signer, best_block_height, logger, pending_events,
+				&send_payment_along_path
 			);
 		}
 		Ok(())
@@ -1276,12 +1276,16 @@ impl OutboundPayments {
 			})?;
 
 		let res = self.pay_route_internal(&route, payment_hash, &recipient_onion,
-			keysend_preimage, None, payment_id, None, onion_session_privs, node_signer,
+			keysend_preimage, None, payment_id, None, &onion_session_privs, node_signer,
 			best_block_height, &send_payment_along_path);
 		log_info!(logger, "Sending payment with id {} and hash {} returned {:?}",
 			payment_id, payment_hash, res);
 		if let Err(e) = res {
-			self.handle_pay_route_err(e, payment_id, payment_hash, route, route_params, router, first_hops, &inflight_htlcs, entropy_source, node_signer, best_block_height, logger, pending_events, &send_payment_along_path);
+			self.handle_pay_route_err(
+				e, payment_id, payment_hash, route, route_params, onion_session_privs, router, first_hops,
+				&inflight_htlcs, entropy_source, node_signer, best_block_height, logger, pending_events,
+				&send_payment_along_path
+			);
 		}
 		Ok(())
 	}
@@ -1433,19 +1437,25 @@ impl OutboundPayments {
 			}
 		};
 		let res = self.pay_route_internal(&route, payment_hash, &recipient_onion, keysend_preimage,
-			invoice_request.as_ref(), payment_id, Some(total_msat), onion_session_privs, node_signer,
+			invoice_request.as_ref(), payment_id, Some(total_msat), &onion_session_privs, node_signer,
 			best_block_height, &send_payment_along_path);
 		log_info!(logger, "Result retrying payment id {}: {:?}", &payment_id, res);
 		if let Err(e) = res {
-			self.handle_pay_route_err(e, payment_id, payment_hash, route, route_params, router, first_hops, inflight_htlcs, entropy_source, node_signer, best_block_height, logger, pending_events, send_payment_along_path);
+			self.handle_pay_route_err(
+				e, payment_id, payment_hash, route, route_params, onion_session_privs, router, first_hops,
+				inflight_htlcs, entropy_source, node_signer, best_block_height, logger, pending_events,
+				send_payment_along_path
+			);
 		}
 	}
 
 	fn handle_pay_route_err<R: Deref, NS: Deref, ES: Deref, IH, SP, L: Deref>(
 		&self, err: PaymentSendFailure, payment_id: PaymentId, payment_hash: PaymentHash, route: Route,
-		mut route_params: RouteParameters, router: &R, first_hops: Vec<ChannelDetails>,
-		inflight_htlcs: &IH, entropy_source: &ES, node_signer: &NS, best_block_height: u32, logger: &L,
-		pending_events: &Mutex<VecDeque<(events::Event, Option<EventCompletionAction>)>>, send_payment_along_path: &SP,
+		mut route_params: RouteParameters, onion_session_privs: Vec<[u8; 32]>, router: &R,
+		first_hops: Vec<ChannelDetails>, inflight_htlcs: &IH, entropy_source: &ES, node_signer: &NS,
+		best_block_height: u32, logger: &L,
+		pending_events: &Mutex<VecDeque<(events::Event, Option<EventCompletionAction>)>>,
+		send_payment_along_path: &SP,
 	)
 	where
 		R::Target: Router,
@@ -1457,10 +1467,24 @@ impl OutboundPayments {
 	{
 		match err {
 			PaymentSendFailure::AllFailedResendSafe(errs) => {
+				self.remove_session_privs(payment_id, route.paths.iter().zip(onion_session_privs.iter()));
 				Self::push_path_failed_evs_and_scids(payment_id, payment_hash, &mut route_params, route.paths, errs.into_iter().map(|e| Err(e)), logger, pending_events);
 				self.find_route_and_send_payment(payment_hash, payment_id, route_params, router, first_hops, inflight_htlcs, entropy_source, node_signer, best_block_height, logger, pending_events, send_payment_along_path);
 			},
 			PaymentSendFailure::PartialFailure { failed_paths_retry: Some(mut retry), results, .. } => {
+				debug_assert_eq!(results.len(), route.paths.len());
+				debug_assert_eq!(results.len(), onion_session_privs.len());
+				let failed_paths = results.iter().zip(route.paths.iter().zip(onion_session_privs.iter()))
+					.filter_map(|(path_res, (path, session_priv))| {
+						match path_res {
+							// While a MonitorUpdateInProgress is an Err(_), the payment is still
+							// considered "in flight" and we shouldn't remove it from the
+							// PendingOutboundPayment set.
+							Ok(_) | Err(APIError::MonitorUpdateInProgress) => None,
+							_ => Some((path, session_priv))
+						}
+					});
+				self.remove_session_privs(payment_id, failed_paths);
 				Self::push_path_failed_evs_and_scids(payment_id, payment_hash, &mut retry, route.paths, results.into_iter(), logger, pending_events);
 				// Some paths were sent, even if we failed to send the full MPP value our recipient may
 				// misbehave and claim the funds, at which point we have to consider the payment sent, so
@@ -1474,11 +1498,13 @@ impl OutboundPayments {
 			},
 			PaymentSendFailure::PathParameterError(results) => {
 				log_error!(logger, "Failed to send to route due to parameter error in a single path. Your router is buggy");
+				self.remove_session_privs(payment_id, route.paths.iter().zip(onion_session_privs.iter()));
 				Self::push_path_failed_evs_and_scids(payment_id, payment_hash, &mut route_params, route.paths, results.into_iter(), logger, pending_events);
 				self.abandon_payment(payment_id, PaymentFailureReason::UnexpectedError, pending_events);
 			},
 			PaymentSendFailure::ParameterError(e) => {
 				log_error!(logger, "Failed to send to route due to parameter error: {:?}. Your router is buggy", e);
+				self.remove_session_privs(payment_id, route.paths.iter().zip(onion_session_privs.iter()));
 				self.abandon_payment(payment_id, PaymentFailureReason::UnexpectedError, pending_events);
 			},
 			PaymentSendFailure::DuplicatePayment => debug_assert!(false), // unreachable
@@ -1518,6 +1544,21 @@ impl OutboundPayments {
 		}
 	}
 
+	// If a payment fails after adding the pending payment but before any HTLCs are locked into
+	// channels, we need to clear the session_privs in order for abandoning the payment to succeed.
+	fn remove_session_privs<'a, I: Iterator<Item = (&'a Path, &'a [u8; 32])>>(
+		&self, payment_id: PaymentId, path_session_priv: I
+	) {
+		if let Some(payment) = self.pending_outbound_payments.lock().unwrap().get_mut(&payment_id) {
+			for (path, session_priv_bytes) in path_session_priv {
+				let removed = payment.remove(session_priv_bytes, Some(path));
+				debug_assert!(removed, "This can't happen as the payment has an entry for this path added by callers");
+			}
+		} else {
+			debug_assert!(false, "This can't happen as the payment was added by callers");
+		}
+	}
+
 	pub(super) fn send_probe<ES: Deref, NS: Deref, F>(
 		&self, path: Path, probing_cookie_secret: [u8; 32], entropy_source: &ES, node_signer: &NS,
 		best_block_height: u32, send_payment_along_path: F
@@ -1549,7 +1590,7 @@ impl OutboundPayments {
 
 		let recipient_onion_fields = RecipientOnionFields::spontaneous_empty();
 		match self.pay_route_internal(&route, payment_hash, &recipient_onion_fields,
-			None, None, payment_id, None, onion_session_privs, node_signer, best_block_height,
+			None, None, payment_id, None, &onion_session_privs, node_signer, best_block_height,
 			&send_payment_along_path
 		) {
 			Ok(()) => Ok((payment_hash, payment_id)),
@@ -1740,7 +1781,7 @@ impl OutboundPayments {
 	fn pay_route_internal<NS: Deref, F>(
 		&self, route: &Route, payment_hash: PaymentHash, recipient_onion: &RecipientOnionFields,
 		keysend_preimage: Option<PaymentPreimage>, invoice_request: Option<&InvoiceRequest>,
-		payment_id: PaymentId, recv_value_msat: Option<u64>, onion_session_privs: Vec<[u8; 32]>,
+		payment_id: PaymentId, recv_value_msat: Option<u64>, onion_session_privs: &Vec<[u8; 32]>,
 		node_signer: &NS, best_block_height: u32, send_payment_along_path: &F
 	) -> Result<(), PaymentSendFailure>
 	where
@@ -1791,30 +1832,12 @@ impl OutboundPayments {
 		let cur_height = best_block_height + 1;
 		let mut results = Vec::new();
 		debug_assert_eq!(route.paths.len(), onion_session_privs.len());
-		for (path, session_priv_bytes) in route.paths.iter().zip(onion_session_privs.into_iter()) {
-			let mut path_res = send_payment_along_path(SendAlongPathArgs {
+		for (path, session_priv_bytes) in route.paths.iter().zip(onion_session_privs.iter()) {
+			let path_res = send_payment_along_path(SendAlongPathArgs {
 				path: &path, payment_hash: &payment_hash, recipient_onion, total_value,
 				cur_height, payment_id, keysend_preimage: &keysend_preimage, invoice_request,
-				session_priv_bytes
+				session_priv_bytes: *session_priv_bytes
 			});
-			match path_res {
-				Ok(_) => {},
-				Err(APIError::MonitorUpdateInProgress) => {
-					// While a MonitorUpdateInProgress is an Err(_), the payment is still
-					// considered "in flight" and we shouldn't remove it from the
-					// PendingOutboundPayment set.
-				},
-				Err(_) => {
-					let mut pending_outbounds = self.pending_outbound_payments.lock().unwrap();
-					if let Some(payment) = pending_outbounds.get_mut(&payment_id) {
-						let removed = payment.remove(&session_priv_bytes, Some(path));
-						debug_assert!(removed, "This can't happen as the payment has an entry for this path added by callers");
-					} else {
-						debug_assert!(false, "This can't happen as the payment was added by callers");
-						path_res = Err(APIError::APIMisuseError { err: "Internal error: payment disappeared during processing. Please report this bug!".to_owned() });
-					}
-				}
-			}
 			results.push(path_res);
 		}
 		let mut has_ok = false;
@@ -1879,17 +1902,23 @@ impl OutboundPayments {
 		F: Fn(SendAlongPathArgs) -> Result<(), APIError>,
 	{
 		self.pay_route_internal(route, payment_hash, &recipient_onion,
-			keysend_preimage, None, payment_id, recv_value_msat, onion_session_privs,
+			keysend_preimage, None, payment_id, recv_value_msat, &onion_session_privs,
 			node_signer, best_block_height, &send_payment_along_path)
 			.map_err(|e| { self.remove_outbound_if_all_failed(payment_id, &e); e })
 	}
 
 	// If we failed to send any paths, remove the new PaymentId from the `pending_outbound_payments`
 	// map as the payment is free to be resent.
 	fn remove_outbound_if_all_failed(&self, payment_id: PaymentId, err: &PaymentSendFailure) {
-		if let &PaymentSendFailure::AllFailedResendSafe(_) = err {
-			let removed = self.pending_outbound_payments.lock().unwrap().remove(&payment_id).is_some();
-			debug_assert!(removed, "We should always have a pending payment to remove here");
+		match err {
+			PaymentSendFailure::AllFailedResendSafe(_)
+				| PaymentSendFailure::ParameterError(_)
+				| PaymentSendFailure::PathParameterError(_) =>
+			{
+				let removed = self.pending_outbound_payments.lock().unwrap().remove(&payment_id).is_some();
+				debug_assert!(removed, "We should always have a pending payment to remove here");
+			},
+			PaymentSendFailure::DuplicatePayment | PaymentSendFailure::PartialFailure { .. }  => {}
 		}
 	}
 

lightning/src/ln/payment_tests.rs

@@ -24,7 +24,7 @@ use crate::types::payment::{PaymentHash, PaymentSecret, PaymentPreimage};
 use crate::ln::chan_utils;
 use crate::ln::msgs::ChannelMessageHandler;
 use crate::ln::onion_utils;
-use crate::ln::outbound_payment::{IDEMPOTENCY_TIMEOUT_TICKS, Retry, RetryableSendFailure};
+use crate::ln::outbound_payment::{IDEMPOTENCY_TIMEOUT_TICKS, ProbeSendFailure, Retry, RetryableSendFailure};
 use crate::routing::gossip::{EffectiveCapacity, RoutingFees};
 use crate::routing::router::{get_route, Path, PaymentParameters, Route, Router, RouteHint, RouteHintHop, RouteHop, RouteParameters};
 use crate::routing::scoring::ChannelUsage;
@@ -1249,6 +1249,7 @@ fn sent_probe_is_probe_of_sending_node() {
 	// First check we refuse to build a single-hop probe
 	let (route, _, _, _) = get_route_and_payment_hash!(&nodes[0], nodes[1], 100_000);
 	assert!(nodes[0].node.send_probe(route.paths[0].clone()).is_err());
+	assert!(nodes[0].node.list_recent_payments().is_empty());
 
 	// Then build an actual two-hop probing path
 	let (route, _, _, _) = get_route_and_payment_hash!(&nodes[0], nodes[2], 100_000);
@@ -4375,3 +4376,77 @@ fn test_non_strict_forwarding() {
 	let events = nodes[0].node.get_and_clear_pending_events();
 	expect_payment_failed_conditions_event(events, payment_hash, false, PaymentFailedConditions::new().blamed_scid(routed_scid));
 }
+
+#[test]
+fn remove_pending_outbounds_on_buggy_router() {
+	// Ensure that if a payment errors due to a bogus route, we'll abandon the payment and remove the
+	// pending outbound from storage.
+	let chanmon_cfgs = create_chanmon_cfgs(2);
+	let node_cfgs = create_node_cfgs(2, &chanmon_cfgs);
+	let node_chanmgrs = create_node_chanmgrs(2, &node_cfgs, &[None, None]);
+	let nodes = create_network(2, &node_cfgs, &node_chanmgrs);
+	create_announced_chan_between_nodes(&nodes, 0, 1);
+
+	let amt_msat = 10_000;
+	let payment_id = PaymentId([42; 32]);
+	let payment_params = PaymentParameters::from_node_id(nodes[1].node.get_our_node_id(), 0)
+		.with_bolt11_features(nodes[1].node.bolt11_invoice_features()).unwrap();
+	let (mut route, payment_hash, _, payment_secret) = get_route_and_payment_hash!(nodes[0], nodes[1], payment_params, amt_msat);
+
+	// Extend the path by itself, essentially simulating route going through same channel twice
+	let cloned_hops = route.paths[0].hops.clone();
+	route.paths[0].hops.extend_from_slice(&cloned_hops);
+	let route_params = route.route_params.clone().unwrap();
+	nodes[0].router.expect_find_route(route_params.clone(), Ok(route.clone()));
+
+	nodes[0].node.send_payment(
+		payment_hash, RecipientOnionFields::secret_only(payment_secret), payment_id, route_params,
+		Retry::Attempts(1) // Even though another attempt is allowed, the payment should fail
+	).unwrap();
+	let events = nodes[0].node.get_and_clear_pending_events();
+	assert_eq!(events.len(), 2);
+	match &events[0] {
+		Event::PaymentPathFailed { failure, payment_failed_permanently, .. } => {
+			assert_eq!(failure, &PathFailure::InitialSend {
+				err: APIError::InvalidRoute { err: "Path went through the same channel twice".to_string() }
+			});
+			assert!(!payment_failed_permanently);
+		},
+		_ => panic!()
+	}
+	match events[1] {
+		Event::PaymentFailed { reason, .. } => {
+			assert_eq!(reason.unwrap(), PaymentFailureReason::UnexpectedError);
+		},
+		_ => panic!()
+	}
+	assert!(nodes[0].node.list_recent_payments().is_empty());
+}
+
+#[test]
+fn remove_pending_outbound_probe_on_buggy_path() {
+	// Ensure that if a probe errors due to a bogus route, we'll return an error and remove the
+	// pending outbound from storage.
+	let chanmon_cfgs = create_chanmon_cfgs(2);
+	let node_cfgs = create_node_cfgs(2, &chanmon_cfgs);
+	let node_chanmgrs = create_node_chanmgrs(2, &node_cfgs, &[None, None]);
+	let nodes = create_network(2, &node_cfgs, &node_chanmgrs);
+	create_announced_chan_between_nodes(&nodes, 0, 1);
+
+	let amt_msat = 10_000;
+	let payment_params = PaymentParameters::from_node_id(nodes[1].node.get_our_node_id(), 0)
+		.with_bolt11_features(nodes[1].node.bolt11_invoice_features()).unwrap();
+	let (mut route, _, _, _) = get_route_and_payment_hash!(nodes[0], nodes[1], payment_params, amt_msat);
+
+	// Extend the path by itself, essentially simulating route going through same channel twice
+	let cloned_hops = route.paths[0].hops.clone();
+	route.paths[0].hops.extend_from_slice(&cloned_hops);
+
+	assert_eq!(
+		nodes[0].node.send_probe(route.paths.pop().unwrap()).unwrap_err(),
+		ProbeSendFailure::ParameterError(
+			APIError::InvalidRoute { err: "Path went through the same channel twice".to_string() }
+		)
+	);
+	assert!(nodes[0].node.list_recent_payments().is_empty());
+}

pending_changelog/3531-buggy-router-leak.txt

@@ -0,0 +1,4 @@
+## Bug Fixes
+
+* Fixed a rare case where a custom router returning a buggy route could result in holding onto a
+	pending payment forever and in some cases failing to generate a PaymentFailed event (#3531).