Fresh install and launch prints ERROR in cling::CIFactory::createCI():

[matthesoundman]

• Checked for duplicates

Describe the bug

After fresh install using brew install cling launching cling with cling from terminal prints an error.

ERROR in cling::CIFactory::createCI():
  resource directory /tmp/cling-20240911-4658-shhoyi/cling-1.1/build/lib/clang/16 not found!

****************** CLING ******************
* Type C++ code and press enter to run it *
*             Type .q to exit             *
*******************************************
[cling]$

Expected behavior

The expected behavior is to not show an error and launch without issues.

To Reproduce

On macOS:

1. Install cling using: brew install cling
2. Run cling using: cling

Setup

1. 1.1

2. ProductName:    macOS
   ProductVersion: 15.0
   BuildVersion:   24A335
   

3. homebrew cling - Homebrew Formulae

Additional context

cling still seems to operate fine when I tried it out, but the error seems odd.

[lkcola]

have you fixed this? i encounter the same problem

[islwx]

have you fixed this? i encounter the same problem
+1
I compiled a cling executable using the method in the README, but encountered the same issue on OSX 14.3

[islwx]

have you fixed this? i encounter the same problem

#531 is a temporary solution and built cling myself, then built Clang before building Cling

[mhdadk]

have you fixed this? i encounter the same problem

#531 is a temporary solution and built cling myself, then built Clang before building Cling

I used the script given in this comment, and it worked for me but with a catch: I could not move the cling binary, nor the build directory in which it exists, after building the cling binary. If I do so, then I still get the same ERROR in cling::CIFactory::createCI().

After building the cling binary, I wanted to move it to a directory on my PATH so that I can use it from anywhere. However, once I did so and launched cling, it gave me the same ERROR in cling::CIFactory::createCI().

Additionally, if I don't move cling outside the directory that it is in, and instead move the entire build directory that the cling binary is in (e.g. moving ~/Downloads/cling-build/* to ~/Desktop/cling-build/*), I get the same error. I am running Ubuntu 24.10.

Interestingly, cling works fine even with the error showing. Additionally, if I move the cling binary back inside the directory that it was in, or if I move the whole parent directory back to where it was, and then launch the cling binary from there, the error goes away.

It seems that the error stems from here:

cling/lib/Interpreter/CIFactory.cpp

Lines 356 to 365 in b2d9db5

	// FIXME: Handle cases, where the cling is part of a library/framework.
	// There we can't rely on the find executable logic.
	if (!llvm::sys::fs::is_directory(resourcePath)) {
	cling::errs()
	<< "ERROR in cling::CIFactory::createCI():\n resource directory "
	<< resourcePath << " not found!\n";
	resourcePath = "";
	} else {
	sArguments.addArgument("-resource-dir", std::move(resourcePath));
	}

After running cling from bash, I can see that resourcePath translates to the same absolute path (i.e. /home/<username>/Downloads/cling/cling-build/lib/clang/18) even after I move the cling binary around. This suggests that resourcePath is not a relative path (such as ../../cling-build/lib/clang/18), which could explain why moving the binary outside the folder it is in causes the error.

[Masterxilo]

Same issue here, just installed the snap package on Ubuntu 24.