-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 44
Support customizable pick list ordering #7897
Copy link
Copy link
Open
Labels
UXUser experience issues that have been reported by a number of usersUser experience issues that have been reported by a number of users
Description
Is your feature request related to a problem? Please describe.
Administrators and collection managers consistently report that the default chronological (ID-based) sorting of pick lists and dropdown fields creates friction during data entry.
Describe the solution you’d like
Provide a native UI control (ideally a dropdown) within the Pick List editor that allows administrators to choose a sort order for any pick list:
- Chronological (creation order)
- Alphabetical (by
title) - Custom (by the
ordinalfield)
This needs to be respected in all places (both comboboxes and in the WorkBench). In my view, the default should be Alphabetical.
Describe alternatives you’ve considered
- High-risk database modifications (ID seeding or index manipulation) to reorder items
- Deleting and re-entering every pick list item in the desired sequence
Reported By
Just a few use cases and historical requests illustrating the need for built-in UI sorting controls:
- Corinna P (CSIRO, March 2022) highlighted operational friction caused by default sort logic during standard workflows.
- Zsuzsanna Papp (Danish Natural History Museums, September 2022) had to re-enter pick list items so they would appear alphabetically on data entry forms.
- Matthew Cruz (University of Michigan, September 2023) resorted to database index seeding to force alphabetical ordering of a large relational list.
- Paul Blom (College of Idaho, May 2024) was forced to delete and re-enter every item to achieve alphabetical order and advocated strongly for a native feature.
- Marion Depraetere (Museum für Naturkunde, April 2026) would need to delete and re-enter every item to achieve alphabetical order, see this post on the Speciforum
Reactions are currently unavailable
Metadata
Metadata
Assignees
Labels
UXUser experience issues that have been reported by a number of usersUser experience issues that have been reported by a number of users