Add Modern Earth benchmark tutorial#369
Add Modern Earth benchmark tutorial#369jaden-lopez wants to merge 3 commits intonatashabatalha:devfrom
Conversation
|
@jaden-lopez, we should remove the absolute paths in the notebook. So, for example, we do: For the ICRCCM file "tyrobinson_earth_PT_and_mixing.atm", we should just embed those as simple numpy arrays in the notebook (i.e. no file). The same goes for the files "modernearth_rfast.pkl" and "modernearth_rfast_thermal.pkl'". I think it is best to embed that information as arrays in the notebook. |
|
@jaden-lopez, the new code seems to have an undefined variable Can you address both of these? |
|
@natashabatalha, The current notebook does a cloud-free reflected light spectrum, then compares that with a cloud-free spectrum computed with rfast (spectrum embeded in notebook). Would it be preferable to just directly reproduce figures in Ty's paper? In other words, we would reproduce Figure 4 (right) and Figure 5 in the rfast paper. For Figure 4, right, this would require adopting Ty's special cloud treatment for Earth (some mixture of ice and water). I have worked out how to do this can can share with Jaden. |
Tutorial that Nick (@Nicholaswogan) and I have been working on that computes modern Earth spectra in reflected light and thermal emission that also recreates Robinson & Salvador 2023 comparing to rfast calculations. Also links to a Zenodo repository (not yet linked in notebook, awaiting edits, but currently here: https://github.com/jajadl/PICASO_spectra_comparison/tree/main) that can calculate reflected spectra for Venus and thermal emission spectra for Mars. Not yet ready to merge but wanted to start the process, any feedback appreciated.